The ICAEW has launched its Future of Tax Commission, with the message that the UK tax system is not fit for purpose. ICAEW research found that the UK tax code, which is more than 23,000 pages long, is the longest and most complicated in the world. The commission, headed by Mark Hoban, former financial secretary to the treasury under David Cameron, will run for two years and report its findings before the next general election, which is expected in 2029. Joe Pickard hears from ICAE CEO Allan Vallance to learn more

The Accountant: How long has this commission been in development?

Access deeper industry intelligence

Experience unmatched clarity with a single platform that combines unique data, AI, and human expertise.

Find out more

Allan Vallance: We’ve developed detailed plans for the commission over recent months in response to the decades of piecemeal change that have created an increasingly complex tax system.

For example, there are disincentives that can hold back work, investment and growth, while AI, automation and demographic change are reshaping our economy.

We believe that the UK’s tax system is unfit for the future without fundamental reform, and that’s why we have taken the initiative to establish and fund this independent commission.

TA: How have people been appointed to the commission?

AV: We’ve announced former Treasury Minister Mark Hoban as chair, and he brings extensive experience of tax policy, government and financial services. We will announce commissioners from across taxation, economics, business and public policy in the next few months.

The commission will be independent, politically impartial and led by evidence, with the chair and commissioners responsible for determining its specific priorities and conclusions.

TA: How many people will be involved and what are their credentials?

AV: Ten to 12 commissioners alongside Mark Hoban as chair will be announced ahead of substantive work, which will begin in January 2027.

TA: Previous reforms, such as the Brydon review, have fallen by the wayside under successive governments. If the commission suggests a route to a better tax system, how likely is it to be adopted?

AV: Although audit reform proposals were eventually scrapped, the collapse of Carillion in 2018 marked a catalyst, which saw regulators, the audit profession and others deliver substantial and significant improvements.

For example, the Big Four firms voluntarily separated their audit and consultancy practices well ahead of the deadline, and the FRC’s quality reports showed that the proportion of good audits has increased in inspection cycles since 2018.

There is little point in producing recommendations that aren’t practical or workable. That is why the commission has been tasked with suggesting how their proposals would be implementable in the real world, with transitionary arrangements in place.

The tax system is in a very different place, but we are concerned that it is not fit for the future without meaningful reform. The commission will report its findings before the next general election, expected in 2029, and we hope it will inform the changes that the tax system needs.

TA: Why is it aiming to release before the next general election? Is ICAEW expecting the commission’s findings to be used in party manifestos?

AV: We want the commission’s work to help drive meaningful reform, which means producing evidence and recommendations that any government can take forward.

The commission will publish findings throughout 2027 and 2028, ahead of its final report in early 2029, giving policymakers opportunities to engage with its work as it develops.

TA: Are there any examples of efficient tax systems in other countries that the UK could adopt or adapt?

AV: The UK has one of the most complex bodies of tax legislation in the world, so there are certainly lessons we can learn from how other countries design and administer their tax systems. But no single country offers a perfect model, and reforms that work elsewhere may not translate directly to the UK’s circumstances.

Our ambition is to develop a practical blueprint fit for the UK’s future economy.