• Register
Return to: Home > Comments > Good accounting makes for better elections

Good accounting makes for better elections

By Ian Ball, chairman, CIPFA International


In many developed countries, the build up to a general election usually follows a similar pattern. After the election is announced, there is a fraught campaign between the main political parties, where, to woo voters, expensive promises are made, many of which are not financially realistic. Yet New Zealand is a country which has broken this mould.

A month before the general election, the country’s government released a pre-election economic and fiscal update (PREFU), which tells voters the current state of the government’s books, including how much tax is flowing into the system and where it is being spent. It also forecasts the financial position of the government over the next four years. The main effect of this document is that it constrains political promises to what can be afforded, and it also has some effect in grounding the electorate’s expectations.

Of course, it does not stop parties from making promises. The National Party and the Labour Party have made some campaign pledges. The Labour Party to scrap University tuition fees for the first three years of study and The National Party to reduce taxes and increase spending on infrastructure. However, these are only made after the release of the fiscal update, to ensure they are based on sound financial information. The provision of such current information to voters is something that other countries would struggle to produce.

The update uses accrual numbers for key fiscal indicators, including forecasts of the government’s net worth. Many countries have introduced accrual-reporting systems, but are not employing the information it provides in their budgetary systems. This means they would be unable to produce such a comprehensive and accurate fiscal update. Consequently, policy pledges made during electoral campaigning in these countries are often not based on the state of the economy and the current and forecast fiscal position of the government in question. It also means that voters are not as financially aware.

New Zealand’s fiscal update enables voters, whether directly or via the media, to be informed about the performance of the Government to date, and the outlook going forward. And so, the electorate has come to regard high quality fiscal information and high standards of fiscal responsibility on the part of politicians as normal. Therefore, there is the perception that their vote will not only hold the existing Government properly to account, but will also reflect their judgements on the affordability of party promises and the potential impact on the Government’s fiscal position.

The publication of the fiscal update has now taken place ahead of elections in New Zealand for more than two decades. Along with other elements of public financial management, it has contributed to high levels of fiscal performance and resilience. Indeed, the New Zealand Government’s net worth has continued to grow, both in absolute terms and as a percentage of GDP, further strengthening its fiscal position.

Underlying the production and release of the fiscal update is the principle that democracies work best when voters are fully informed, and it discourages political parties from promising what is either not feasible or not fiscally responsible. Something that other countries should learn lessons from and encourage during electoral campaigning.

Top Content

    IRBA: taking transparency to the next level

    Bernard Agulhas, chief executive officer at the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA), talks to Joe Pickard about the introduction of mandatory audit firm rotation, and the future of the Big Four in South Africa

    read more

    Sustainable investment: Accountants hold the key

    The US Institute of Management Accountants has a plan to remind professionals that they have the skills to take leadership roles in ESG investing. Carlos Martin Tornero writes

    read more

    IASB: progress towards global standards

    In an extract from a speech given at the Accounting Standards Board of Japan conference in Tokyo, Hans Hoogervorst looks at a possible return of the amortisation of goodwill to IFRS, and the standards’ progress in Japan

    read more

    IMA: developing diversity

    At the end of the July, the Institute of Management Accountants (IMA) appointed Linda Devonish-Mills as its first director of diversity and inclusion. Joe Pickard discusses with her what she plans to do in her new role

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.