• Register
Return to: Home > Comments > Editor's letter: Who will have the brexit cake and who will eat it?

Editor's letter: Who will have the brexit cake and who will eat it?

What the UK wants, the European Union can’t possibly give it. It is not a question of punishment as it has been suggested in some parts. But while the UK wants and needs to retain its prestigious position as the English speaking high standards doorstep of the EU market, for the EU what is at stake is the sustainability of a project which has come close to being a white elephant.

And this dichotomy brings about an important problem for citizens both in the UK and the EU: they are at the mercy of the short-sightedness of politicians more interested in their careers rather than building a future for the next generations.
Time is an important and worrying aspect of Brexit which has been left overlooked so far. Interestingly the UK voted in the Brexit referendum on 23 June 2016, just over a month to the day of the centenary of the Sykes–Picot Agreement (May 1916).

The agreement defined the sphere of influence of the UK and France in the Middle East and there is little doubt that the current situation in the region from Syria to Palestine and Saudi Arabia is directly linked to this agreement.

Political decisions taken in secret a hundred years ago by politicians had tremendous consequences to this day for the whole world: setting a region in flame and fostering tension and insecurity globally.

Both UK and EU politicians should remember this lesson from history.

It is very unlikely that an economic and politic integration build over 60 years will be unwound in two, as ACCA UK head John Williams tells us. Stripping out Brexit of all politics then raises a whole lot of questions around the practicalities of doing business from the UK to the EU and the other way around. Amongst those questions: is there the infrastructure to hold Lorries at the border if we were to return to a hard border? What about cooling containers to preserve all the fruits coming from Spain while they clear custom?  What will be the impact on prices for UK consumers?

In its paper entitled Future Customs arrangements a future partnership paper, the UK government suggests two scenarios stating that it seek to have an arrangement that facilitates the freest and most frictionless trade possible in goods between the UK and the EU.

But the UK can’t have the cake and eat it.  

The so called “deal” that the UK and the EU leaders will broke will have to facilitate business in the short term and will have to be satisfactory to their current and respective electorate. But it will also have to stand the test of time so that in 100 years’ time it will be lauded rather than condemned.

Top Content

    Brexit negotiations: Making simple complicated

    Stepping away from the politics, ACCA UK head John Williams talks about the practical implications of Brexit for businesses’ supply chains and how the accountancy profession’s pragmatism could be a welcome. But, when it comes to Brexit, by its very nature, the politics can’t stay away for too long. Interview by Vincent Huck.

    read more

    TA & IAB 2017 Awards: Prem Sikka granted the Editor's award

    Accounting professor Prem Sikka will receive a special editor’s award from The Accountant and International Accounting Bulletin at a one-day conference and awards dinner in London on 4 October

    read more

    Australia country survey: scandals and struggles

    CPA Australia hit the headlines over excessive pay, bad management, intimidation, and a ‘celebrity’ CEO departing with a generous payoff. After a parliamentary inquiry and an independent review due to report, can determined members get the CPA they want? Tom Ravlic reports

    read more

    Technical brief: Kazakhstan

    To what extent has Kazakhstan acted on the world bank’s recomendations from a decade ago?

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.