• Register
Return to: Home > News > Regulation > US and Chinese regulatory standoff continues

US and Chinese regulatory standoff continues

The US Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) has again granted an extension order to the court hearings on the six months ban prohibiting Big Four Chinese firms to provide services to US listed Chinese companies.

This is the third extension order issued by the SEC in this matter since January 2014 when a SEC Judge ruled that all of the Big Four Chinese joint ventures as well as BDO former Chinese firm, DaHua, had violated the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, and that they should be banned from working for any US-listed Chinese companies for the next six months.

The Big Four Chinese firms and the SEC Division of Enforcement have been negotiating a settlement since the ruling and the SEC repeated extension orders suggest that progress is being made.

However, parallel to this negotiation, US Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) negotiations for regulatory access to China have been ongoing for a decade.

According to Peking University's Guanghua School of Management professor Paul Gillis this could be a regulatory impasse.

In his latest blog Gillis wrote that the issue remained straightforward. "The PCAOB wants to do joint inspections side by side with Chinese regulators, while China wants the PCAOB to accept their work. The SEC wants unfettered access to documents related to US listed Chinese companies while China wants to prevent disclosure of information that could be harmful to China's interests," he wrote.

"The positions of all parties are reasonable, and there is little scope for anyone to compromise."

In July, PCAOB chairman James Doty told The Accountant the US regulator was hopeful for an imminent agreement.

"We had very important and productive meetings with both China's Securities Regulatory Commission and the Ministry of Finance," he said. "I also believe the PCAOB was able to reach a joint commitment with both of those regulatory agencies to move forward with a cooperation that would enable us to conduct the first inspection of a PCAOB-registered mainland Chinese audit firm before the end of the year."

With the end of the year fast approaching seems the regulatory impasse described by Gillis is still very much a reality. However Gillis believes Chinese and US regulators will ultimately reach an agreement, but that it might not be to the US advantage.

"I believe that Chinese regulators will have the upper hand in these negotiations. Knowing that U.S. regulators are unlikely to delist Chinese stocks, they will seek a deal that gives up no meaningful turf while allowing US regulators to save face," he wrote. "Since the PCAOB and SEC appear to be negotiating separately, Chinese regulators are likely to play them off each other."

Related articles:

Big Four China firms in settlement talks with SEC

Countdown to PCAOB's inspections of Chinese audit firms

 

 

 

Top Content

    IRBA: taking transparency to the next level

    Bernard Agulhas, chief executive officer at the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA), talks to Joe Pickard about the introduction of mandatory audit firm rotation, and the future of the Big Four in South Africa

    read more

    Sustainable investment: Accountants hold the key

    The US Institute of Management Accountants has a plan to remind professionals that they have the skills to take leadership roles in ESG investing. Carlos Martin Tornero writes

    read more

    IASB: progress towards global standards

    In an extract from a speech given at the Accounting Standards Board of Japan conference in Tokyo, Hans Hoogervorst looks at a possible return of the amortisation of goodwill to IFRS, and the standards’ progress in Japan

    read more

    IMA: developing diversity

    At the end of the July, the Institute of Management Accountants (IMA) appointed Linda Devonish-Mills as its first director of diversity and inclusion. Joe Pickard discusses with her what she plans to do in her new role

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.